1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
COMPANY Dick Bowman Jordan Disposal Service/ Gator Industrial Oilfield Pipe & Supply Inc. ISI - G&G Dozer RD Johnson Excavating Company Remediation Services Inc. Environmental Works McPherson Wrecking Inc. Anderson Excavating Co. Rand Construction Company Dore & Associates Benchmark Construction DECO K&W Services LLC DT Specialized Services Inc.
BID PRICE $0.00 $169000 p;us Boiler Asbestos @ $250,000** $495,000 for demo +$15000Haz Waste Disposal** Less $200,000 Recycle credit                           Total $310,000   $388,419 ($0 for demolition; Bid includes $241,250 for Boiler Abatement and $147,169 for Hazard Material Collectionand disposal) $399000 Less $180,000 for recycle credit  Total $219,000 $447041.31 Phase I    $620,584.85Phase II $275,000 for asbestos    $175,000 demolition                   TOTAL $450,000 $595,000.00 $649,900.00 $998,950.00 $1,090,100.00 $1,300,900.00 $1,494,000.00 $1,862,648.00 $1,899,000.00
ADD ADMIN BLDG Asbestos Removal (discussed with 4 lowest bidders) _ Estimate $31,175 Not provided $44,000.00 $33,000.00 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Haz Waste Disposal   included in Bid / EMA provided unit pricing for additional items **incl in bid $15,000 plus unit prices for disposal include in Bid147,169 Flourescents and Ballasts included / Unit Prices provided for additional items incl in bid self preformed incl in proposal _ _ flourescents / ballasts incl  any other unknown s negotiated _ unit price unit price   $100,000 incl in bid
Addendum No. 1
 
Addendum No. 2  
missing #2
Electronic copy RFP
not provided
 
 
blank CD
Contact Information 20388 County Road 379P.O. Box 183St. Joseph, MO 64502 300 North Blackcat Rd.             Joplin, MO 64801 P.O. Box 189                           Dewey, OK 74029 215 S Laura St                           Wichita, KS 67211-1516                                       G&G - 1875 US Highway 75            P.O. Box 6                           Caney, KS 67333-8507 1705 N. 1399 Rd           Lawrence, KS 66046 2735 S. 10th Street                    P.O. Box 587             Independence, KS 67301 1455 E. Chestnut Expy.           Springfield, MO 65802 2333 Barton Road         Grantville, KS 66429 1920 Dorcas St            Omaha, NE 68108-3890 1428 W. 9th Street                  Kansas City, MO 64101 900 Harry S. Truman Pkwy Bay City, MI 48706 5610 SW Topeka Blvd.          Topeka, KS 66609 7701 Wilson Rd         Kansas City, MO 64125-1357 5644 Granada Lane      Roeland Park, KS 64502 25701 E. Admiral Place          P.O. Box 616           Catoosa, OK 74015
Subcontractors/ Subconsultants "Bowman Dismantling has worked in conjunction with Environmental Technical Services, ST. Joseph, MO, Owner Marty Altman." subsidiary company - Blackcat Trucking, LLC                         Spray Services Inc- Asbestos removal Dale Brothers                      Titan Environmental   Occidental Chem Corp G&G Dozer Kaw Valley Wrecking ACM LLC                     Wichita ,KS CAS                                        New Horizons Enviro Remediation LLC none anticipated at this time. Asbestos Abatement Contractors, Inc.                          DRS -Demolition, Recovery & Salvage  DSI - Dedicated Services Inc. To be determined Midland Wrecking            New Horizons Environmental New Horizons ISI Environmental Services                           Greg Bair Trackhoe Asbestos Handlers          Tulsa, OK
Asbestos abatement- BOILER "No visible signs of ACM were noted." ** $250,000 add for 10,000sf ($25/sf  if 7000sf then $175,000) NOT IDENTIFIED Included in bid ($241,250) $180,000 Included in bid ($269,100) Boiler Abatement $60,000 each $100000 incl in Bid NOT INCLUDED IN BID PRICE ADD $22/sf $201,400 incl in bid INCLUDED $115,000 or $33 /sf Included in base bid Included in base bid ($500,000) $250,000 incl in bid
Estimated asbestos amount (ft.2) 10,000 ft2 _ 7000 ft2 7000 sf lump sum bid _ __ not provided _ _ _ _   not quantified
Hazwoper Training none listed (10) employees that are certified with 40-Hours of Hazwoper Training  yes yes yes yes EWI personnel are all 40-hr HAZWOPER trained We have trained and accredited AHERA asbestos building inspector, AHERA asbestos supervisor and AHERA asbestos abatement contractor/supervisor personnel on staff who will be on the project site for the duration of work.     Appropriate documentation for asbestos removal     yes 40 Hour Hazwoper Course
Experience 30+ years 17 years direct experience with demolition of chemical and explosive plants 30 years 35 years 35 years since 1993 Founded in 1992 Founded in 1966 formed in 1958, incorporated in 1966 Facilities Const Group in 2003 Founded in the 1958 In operation since 1987 DECO Companies Inc. has over 25 years of experience in demolition, excavation and recycling. 35 yrs 1950
Work Crew 5 crew members with over 10+ years 3 crews _ 21 full time employees   Up to 8 operators at a time _ _ over 100 people with varying degrees of experience & expertise _ 300 companywide _ _ _ _
Environmental Consultant   EMA - St. Louis Titan Environmental Services ISI  _   Wichita, KS                                 New Horizons used for Asbestos abatement             Unit price abatement of boiler  $30.00/SF
Removal of asbestos piping $30.00/LF
Removal of asbestos roofing  $1.60/SF
Complete asbestos inspection of facility $3500.00
 RSI to preform waste characterization and disposal self _ _ _ self New Horizons New Horizons ISI Environmental Services                           self
Detail of work associated with bid Will remove all structure, concrete down to 18" as described in the ivitation to bid for $0.00 amount of dollars, no cost to the City of Lawrence, KS Included in this base bid is the abatement of any asbestos found on any flat roof areas and asbestos from the boiler in the administration room Ballast, Mercury from thermostats,PCB … Dale Bros to do Conc/ Bldg Demo Detail plan submitted As listed in RFP As listed in RFP EWI proposes to complete waste consolidation, waste disposal, and demolition as outlined in the RFP documents for a lump sum of $175,000 Detailed list included with bid indicating each structure and what equipment is going to be used for its demolition. Anderson Excavating Co. will meet all the requirements listed in the bid package (MINUS the asbestos removal) for the sum of: $645,000.00   As listed in RFP As listed in RFP Evironmentally we have included the boiler removal and a survey of the property. As listed in RFP As listed in RFP
Exclusions NONE Storage tanks $25.00/ft2       Exterior Pipe - $50.00/LF                                Steam Drums - $25.00/SF            estimated 10,000 SF Unit Pricing provided for additional Haz Waste Disposal none Grading and import of fill material not included with the bid.   EWI will complete the abatement required for demolition in accordance with the unit rates not-to-exceed $275,000 _ DOES NOT include asbestos removal _ _ Doesn't include asbestos or hazardous materials abate on the site EXCEPT for boilers _ _ _
MISC 5000 tons x $170.00/ ton = $850,000                     Estimates for landfill, concrete grinding, environmental work, removal of AMC, etc @ approximately $350,000 includes Haz Waste disposal  Buliding and foundation demolition & disposal Phase I & II total price $495,000    Environmental oversight & Hazardous waste disposla $15,000    $200,000 credit for the steel structure recycled from the plant _ New Horizons used for Asbestos abatement             Unit price abatement of boiler  $30.00/SF
Removal of asbestos piping $30.00/LF
Removal of asbestos roofing  $1.60/SF
Complete asbestos inspection of facility $3500.00
   Asbestos Survey/Sampling $11,400 lump Boiler Abatement $60,000 each  Tank Abatement $11.95/SF  Piping Abatement $21.60/LF   Roof Abatement $1.50/SF Perform the required asbestos inpsection of the buildings.  Make the rquired notificaions of demolition to KDHE.  Make the required notification for asbesos abatement of the boiler house to KDHE.  Obtain any required deolition permits.  Locate and cap the buidling sanitary sewers as close to the building as practical. Asbestos Removal Unit Prices:   Boilers  $22.00/SF                        Flat Roofing $6.00/SF                   Pipe  $25.00/LN. FT. ABATEMENT OF PIPE:  $19.97/LF      ABATEMENT OF ROOF MEMBRANES:  $1.25/SF _ Our price for complete demolition according to the specifications in the RFP is as follows. Pricing does not include any asbestos or hazardous materials abatement on the site EXCEPT for the boilers. _ _ _
Safety Program written statement of no claims "If necessary I (Dick Bowman) can prepare any documents needed as requested by the city of Lawrence, KS."  YES yes yes yes  yes YES _ YES, safety plan submitted YES, included yes Safety Manual Provided Safety Handbook provided yes Safety Manual provided
Phase I as listed in RFP JDS/GI anticipates project completion for both Phase I and Phase II to be 180 days total from the date of site move in.  5 months 120 days Total Phase 1 and 2 - 4mos 130 days EWI plans to have Phase I completed within four months of award, and have the entire project completed within nine months. As outlined in RFP As outlined in RFP As outlined in RFP As outlined in RFP As outlined in RFP Barring unforeseen circumstances, the project completion can be performed within the two phases of the job (Phase 1 120 calendar days, Phase 2 270 calendar days).  meet RFP As outlined in RFP
Phase II as listed in RFP 4 months 270 days   270 days As outlined in RFP As outlined in RFP As outlined in RFP As outlined in RFP As outlined in RFP meet RFP As outlined in RFP
Recycling Credit    over 2000 tons will split with City after expenses (freight) 50/50  $200,000 _ $180,000 credit plus over 1500 tons contractor will share recycled materials @ 75/25 split  _ not listed not listed not listed not listed not listed not listed _ not listed not listed
Estimated tons of steel to be recycled 5,000 2000   3000 - 5000 1500 not available not listed not listed not listed not listed not listed 3000 _ not listed not listed
                               
Equipment track hoe excavator with grapple, Track loader, torches, concrete grinder JDS/GI maintain our own equipment, while having a wide variety and updating frequently, we are not limited by lease contracts or accessibility.  A list of our equipment is available upon request.   sufficient to preform work sufficient to preform work excavation / demolition equipment satifactory to complete all work sufficient to preform work   Cat 225 Excavator w/shear attachment  Cat 320 Excavator w/Hydraulic Hammer Cat 240 Excavator w/grapple attachment Bobcat Skid Loaders  Mack roll-off trucks  Hydraulic excavators with shear, pulverizing and processing attachments, as well as bucket and grapple attachment, off-road trucks, traxcavators _ _ Yes yes KWS will provide state of the art equipment ranging from mobile shears, grapples, magnets, crushers, and any other equipment necessary to insure a safe, fast, and efficient demolition plan. sufficient to preform work
References supplied supplied supplied supplied supplied supplied supplied yes yes   yes yes yes yes yes
Similar Previous Work yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes   yes yes yes yes yes
WASTE STREAM TRACKING
By Weight no at disposal site weigh in KC or OK  at disposal site on site Varied based on disposal site For any materials removed as part of the demolition, EWI will document the quantity, waste description, item description, ultimate disposition, transportation company, and disposal or recycling facility used for the disposition of all materials removed as part of the demolition.  _ _ on site _ _ at disposal site _ at disposal site
With Spreadsheet no yes  yes yes yes spreadsheet _ _ yes yes _ yes _ yes
misc Truck numbers will be noted _ _ _ _   _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
OTHER INCOMPLETE, no safety program, no financial, no plan, no schedule _ _ _ _ _ _ Lacking detail of work plan Lacking detail of work plan _ _ _ _ _ _