| 2016 RFP Disposal Price Comparison | ||||||||||||||||
| Tradebe Environmental Services | Stericycle Environmental Solutions | Clean Harbors Environmental Services | ||||||||||||||
| DOT Class | Description | Unit | Disposal Method | # Shipped 2015 Through Contractor | Unit Cost Including Container | Total Cost Including Container | Unit Cost Without Container | Total Cost Without Container | Unit Cost Including Container | Total Cost Including Container | Unit Cost Without Container | Total Cost Without Container | Unit Cost Including Container | Total Cost Including Container | Unit Cost Without Container | Total Cost Without Container |
| 2.1 | Aerosol | 55 Gallon | Incineration | 54 | $ 217.65 | $ 11,753.10 | $ 182.65 | $ 9,863.10 | $ 188.00 | $ 10,152.00 | $ 155.00 | $ 8,370.00 | $ 212.00 | $ 11,448.00 | $ 164.00 | $ 8,856.00 |
| 2.1 | Aerosol | CYB | Fuel Blend | $ 640.59 | $ - | $ 580.59 | $ - | $ 476.00 | $ - | $ 438.00 | $ - | $ 654.00 | $ 574.00 | |||
| 2.1 | Propane (Small) | Each | Recycled | 250 | $ 17.00 | $ 4,250.00 | $ 17.00 | $ 4,250.00 | $ 9.00 | $ 2,250.00 | $ 9.00 | $ 2,250.00 | $ 10.00 | $ 2,500.00 | $ 8.50 | $ 2,125.00 |
| 2.1, 2.2, 2.3 | Pressurized Gas Cylinders | Each | Recycled | $ 40.00 | $ - | $ 40.00 | $ - | CBC | CBC | CBC | CBC | |||||
| 3 | Flammable Liquids | 55 Gallon | Energy Recovery | 17 | $ 117.65 | $ 2,000.05 | $ 82.35 | $ 1,399.95 | $ 81.00 | $ 1,377.00 | $ 55.00 | $ 935.00 | $ 106.00 | $ 1,802.00 | $ 58.00 | $ 986.00 |
| 3 | Oil base Paint | 55 Gallon | Energy Recovery | $ 252.65 | $ - | $ 217.65 | $ - | $ 81.00 | $ - | $ 55.00 | $ - | $ 128.00 | $ - | $ 80.00 | $ - | |
| 3 | Oil base Paint | Cubic Yard | Energy Recovery | 39 | $ 615.59 | $ 24,008.01 | $ 555.59 | $ 21,668.01 | $ 313.33 | $ 12,219.87 | $ 275.00 | $ 10,725.00 | $ 335.00 | $ 13,065.00 | $ 275.00 | $ 10,725.00 |
| 3 | PCB Contaminated Flammable Liquid | 55 Gallon | Incineration | $ 833.84 | $ - | $ 798.81 | $ - | $ 476.00 | $ - | $ 450.00 | $ - | $ 280.00 | $ - | $ 232.00 | $ - | |
| 3(6.1) | Flammable Toxics | 55 Gallon | Incineration | 1 | $ 217.65 | $ 217.65 | $ 182.65 | $ 182.65 | $ 267.00 | $ 267.00 | $ 241.00 | $ 241.00 | $ 239.00 | $ 239.00 | $ 191.00 | $ 191.00 |
| 4.1 | Flammable Solids | 5 Gallon | Incineration | 1 | $ 75.99 | $ 75.99 | $ 60.99 | $ 60.99 | $ 117.31 | $ 117.31 | $ 111.00 | $ 111.00 | $ 107.00 | $ 107.00 | $ 90.00 | $ 90.00 |
| 4.2 | Spontaneously Combustible | 5 Gallon | Incineration | 1 | $ 217.99 | $ 217.99 | $ 202.99 | $ 202.99 | $ 117.31 | $ 117.31 | $ 111.00 | $ 111.00 | $ 118.00 | $ 118.00 | $ 101.00 | $ 101.00 |
| 4.3 | Dangerous when Wet | 5 Gallon | Incineration | 1 | $ 217.99 | $ 217.99 | $ 202.99 | $ 202.99 | $ 147.00 | $ 147.00 | $ 140.00 | $ 140.00 | $ 118.00 | $ 118.00 | $ 101.00 | $ 101.00 |
| 5.1 | Oxidizer | 55 Gallon | Incineration | 2 | $ 442.65 | $ 885.30 | $ 407.65 | $ 815.30 | $ 452.00 | $ 904.00 | $ 400.00 | $ 800.00 | $ 239.00 | $ 478.00 | $ 191.00 | $ 382.00 |
| 5.2 | Organic Peroxides | 5 Gallon | Incineration | 1 | $ 217.99 | $ 217.99 | $ 202.99 | $ 202.99 | $ 146.36 | $ 146.36 | $ 140.00 | $ 140.00 | $ 118.00 | $ 118.00 | $ 101.00 | $ 101.00 |
| 6.1 | Toxic Solids | 55 Gallon | Treatment | 23 | $ 417.65 | $ 9,605.95 | $ 382.65 | $ 8,800.95 | $ 396.00 | $ 9,108.00 | $ 350.00 | $ 8,050.00 | $ 239.00 | $ 5,497.00 | $ 191.00 | $ 4,393.00 |
| 6.1(3) | Toxic Liquids, Flammable | 55 Gallon | Incineration | 38 | $ 367.65 | $ 13,970.70 | $ 332.65 | $ 12,640.70 | $ 252.00 | $ 9,576.00 | $ 200.00 | $ 7,600.00 | $ 239.00 | $ 9,082.00 | $ 191.00 | $ 7,258.00 |
| 8 | Corrosive Liquids (Acids/Bases) | 55 Gallon | Treatment | 14 | $ 252.65 | $ 3,537.10 | $ 217.65 | $ 3,047.10 | $ 225.00 | $ 3,150.00 | $ 180.00 | $ 2,520.00 | $ 259.00 | $ 3,626.00 | $ 191.00 | $ 2,674.00 |
| 8 | Elemental Mercury | 5 Gallon | Recycled | 1 | $ 270.99 | $ 270.99 | $ 255.99 | $ 255.99 | $ 111.00 | $ 111.00 | $ 104.00 | $ 104.00 | $ 240.00 | $ 240.00 | $ 223.00 | $ 223.00 |
| 8 | Mercury Compounds/Debris | 5 Gallon | Recycled | 1 | $ 245.99 | $ 245.99 | $ 230.99 | $ 230.99 | $ 189.00 | $ 189.00 | $ 182.00 | $ 182.00 | $ 240.00 | $ 240.00 | $ 223.00 | $ 223.00 |
| 8 | Household Batteries - Alkaline | 55 Gallon | Haz Landfill | 11 | $ 267.65 | $ 2,944.15 | $ 232.65 | $ 2,559.15 | $ 155.00 | $ 1,705.00 | $ 129.00 | $ 1,419.00 | $ 306.67 | $ 3,373.37 | $ 250.00 | $ 2,750.00 |
| 8 | Household Batteries - Alkaline | 55 Gallon | Recycled | 11 | $ - | $ - | $ 476.00 | $ 450.00 | $ - | $ - | ||||||
| 8 | Household Batteries - NiCad | 5 Gallon | Recycled | $ 68.09 | $ - | $ 53.09 | $ - | $ 41.56 | $ - | $ 35.20 | $ - | $ 107.00 | $ - | $ 90.00 | $ - | |
| 8 | Household Batteries - Mercury | 5 Gallon | Recycled | $ 177.99 | $ - | $ 162.99 | $ - | $ 137.00 | $ - | $ 130.00 | $ - | $ 256.00 | $ - | $ 239.00 | $ - | |
| 8 | Household Batteries - Lithium | 5 Gallon | Recycled | $ 110.00 | $ - | $ 110.00 | $ - | $ 59.00 | $ - | $ 52.40 | $ - | $ 211.00 | $ - | $ 106.00 | $ - | |
| 9 | PCB Ballasts | 55 Gallon | Haz Landfill | $ 293.65 | $ - | $ 258.65 | $ - | $ 408.00 | $ - | $ 380.00 | $ - | $ 107.00 | $ - | $ 90.00 | $ - | |
| NR | Latex Paint Bulk | 55 Gallon | Landfill | 6 | $ 136.65 | $ 819.90 | $ 101.65 | $ 609.90 | $ 173.00 | $ 1,038.00 | $ 146.00 | $ 876.00 | $ 138.00 | $ 828.00 | $ 95.00 | $ 570.00 |
| NR | Latex Paint | Cubic Yard | Landfill | 95 | $ 405.59 | $ 38,531.05 | $ 345.59 | $ 32,831.05 | $ 235.00 | $ 22,325.00 | $ 196.00 | $ 18,620.00 | $ 285.00 | $ 27,075.00 | $ 205.00 | $ 19,475.00 |
| NR | Latex Paint | Cubic Yard | Recycled | $ - | $ - | $ 389.00 | $ 351.00 | $ - | $ - | |||||||
| NR | Antifreeze | 55 Gallon | Recycled | $ 152.65 | $ - | $ 117.65 | $ - | $ 173.00 | $ - | $ 146.00 | $ - | $ 244.00 | $ - | $ 196.00 | $ - | |
| NR | Automotive Oil | 55 Gallon | Energy Recovery | 4 | $ 118.65 | $ 474.60 | $ 83.65 | $ 334.60 | $ 81.00 | $ 324.00 | $ 55.00 | $ 220.00 | $ 151.00 | $ 604.00 | $ 64.00 | $ 256.00 |
| NR | Automotive Oil | 55 Gallon | Recycled | $ - | $ - | $ 105.45 | $ - | $ 79.45 | $ - | $ - | $ - | |||||
| Totals | $ 114,244.50 | $ 100,159.40 | $ 75,223.85 | $ 63,414.00 | $ 80,558.37 | $ 61,480.00 | ||||||||||